Photo Essay: Powerful Images Depict the ‘Before and After’ of Israeli Hostages
Error: Contact form not found.
by Debbie Weiss

Hostages who were abducted by Hamas terrorists during the Oct. 7 attack on Israel are handed over by Hamas terrorists to members of the International Committee of the Red Cross, as part of a hostages-prisoners swap deal between Hamas and Israel amid a temporary truce, in an unknown location in the Gaza Strip, in this screengrab taken from video released Nov. 27, 2023. Photo: Hamas Military Wing/Handout via REUTERS
When Hamas terrorists rampaged across southern Israel on Oct. 7, they not only murdered 1,200 people, injured thousands more, and abducted 240 others as hostages back to Gaza; they also changed the lives of thousands of families forever.
The devastating impact of Hamas’ onslaught on survivors of the Oct. 7 massacre can be seen in newly unveiled photos of some of the hostages who have been released, as well as family members of others still in captivity in Gaza.
The side-by-side photos — from both before and after the Hamas atrocities — are part of a project by photographers Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat. The idea behind the images was to highlight the urgency of releasing the elderly hostages, amid reports of their declining health. Indeed, a flurry of recent reports, backed up by official testimony from Israeli health officials, have highlighted the trauma and torture — both physical and psychological — that the hostages endured.

Lior Peri with his father, Haim Peri, seen with newspaper, who is being held hostage in Gaza. Photo: Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat
Derhy is the wife of Lior Peri, whose father Haim Peri, 80, is still being held hostage in Gaza without his life-saving heart medications. The idea for the photo series was born when Lior revisited his father’s front porch after accompanying a TV crew to the plundered kibbutz. He recalled a serene moment captured two years ago when he and his father sat there immersed in the weekend papers.
On a whim, Lior asked his sister, Noam, to take a photo of him in the same spot, now marked by the absence of his father. In the new photo, Lior sits alone beside an empty chair, with a poster of his father hanging on the door of his destroyed home.

Yocheved and Oded Lifshitz. Oded is still being held hostage in Gaza. Photo: Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat
The Lifshitz family, neighbors to the Peris, share a similar plight. Yocheved Lifshitz, 85, was released after 17 days in captivity, and reported seeing Haim Peri alive in Gaza. Her husband, Oded, 83, remains in captivity. The photographers captured the ruins of the Lifshitz home and the burned-out carcass of Oded’s piano, in stark contrast to the photo taken before the attacks which shows the smiling couple posing in front of the piano.

Nurit Cooper is pictured with her grandson and husband, Amiram, who is still being held hostage in Gaza. Photo: Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat
Nurit Cooper is pictured with her grandson and husband, Amiram, 84.
Nurit, 79, was released together with Yocheved Lifshitz. Amiram, one of the founders of Nir Oz, saw the settlement of the Western Negev as his life’s mission.
Like the others featured in the photos, Amiram is still in Gaza without his medications.

Ohad Munder, flanked by his grandparents Ruthy and Avraham Munder. Avraham is still being held hostage in Gaza. Photo: Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat
The “before” photo depicts a smiling boy, Ohad Munder, flanked by his grandparents at a table on their porch in Kibbutz Nir Oz, their plates piled with food. The “after” photo is haunting both for all its striking similarities to the original — the same setting, the same hand placed affectionately on Ohad’s shoulder by his grandmother — and for its stark differences: The plates now sit empty, the smiles have vanished, and most jarringly of all, so has Ohad’s grandfather, Avraham, 78. Instead, a poster of him and the words “abducted” in Hebrew are tacked onto the wall.

Photo: Sharon Derhy and Michal Chitayat
Ruthy Munder, 78, her daughter Keren, 54, and grandson Ohad, 9, were taken captive by Hamas as part of the terror group’s savage attack on Oct. 7. They were released after 49 days. Avraham, who suffers from various chronic illnesses, is still being held captive in Gaza. The Munders’ other son, Roi, was murdered in his home in Nir Oz on Oct. 7.

Tamir Hershkovitz lighting the menorah in the ravaged home of his parents Noam and Maayana Hershkovitz, who were murdered by Hamas on Oct. 7, on the first night of Hanukkah. Photo: Gadi Kabelo
The photo series was released on the first day of Hanukkah, the Jewish festival of lights. Also on that day, Tamir Hershkovitz, son of Noah and Maayana Hershkovitz who were murdered on Oct. 7, was photographed lighting a menorah in the ruins of his parents’ home in Be’eri.
The crooked, rusty menorah, which belonged to Tamir’s late grandfather and Holocaust survivor Yosef, was one of the only items to survive the attack on their home.

Photo: Gadi Kabelo
Singing Maoz Tzur, a song about miracles traditionally sung after lighting the menorah, Tamir said he was “happy.”
“I choose to be happy for my parents,” the Yedioth Aharanoth newspaper cited Tamir as saying.
Israel Strikes Hezbollah Stronghold in Beirut Despite Truce, Iran Threatens to Retaliate
Arab Israeli Terrorist Kills One, Wounds Five in Multi-Site Shooting Attack Across Central Israel
Thousands of Belgian Academics Urge Universities to Cut Ties With Israeli Institutions in Expanding Boycott Drive
Republican Senator Calls on Florida Stadium to Cancel Kanye West Show Over Antisemitic Comments
Iran Reaffirms Support for Hezbollah With Wider Peace Deal in Doubt
Romanians Convicted of Stabbing Journalist in UK, Prosecutors Say They Acted for Iran
US Preparing Draft Resolution Condemning Iran at IAEA, Diplomats Say
Iran Using Lebanon as Bargaining Chip in US Talks, Lebanese President Says
Iran World Cup Soccer Players Granted Visas to Enter the US, Says White House Official
Israel Plans First Embassy in Slovenia, Says Foreign Minister





Israel Strikes Hezbollah Stronghold in Beirut Despite Truce, Iran Threatens to Retaliate
Arab Israeli Terrorist Kills One, Wounds Five in Multi-Site Shooting Attack Across Central Israel



