The West Bank and the Lessons of the Gaza Conflagration
Error: Contact form not found.
by Gershon Hacohen

A trail of smoke is seen as a rocket is fired from the Gaza Strip toward Israel, Nov. 13, 2019. Photo: Reuters / Mohammed Salem.
The latest Gaza conflagration was all but predictable. Though lacking advanced weapons systems such as fighter aircraft, tanks, and artillery, Hamas and Islamic Jihad have constructed a formidable military system that fits their strategic needs by neutralizing key aspects of Israel’s military supremacy.
So much so, that it is arguable that the two terror groups have achieved strategic balance with Israel — not in the sense of being able to conquer (however small) parts of Israel or to prevent the IDF from invading Gaza, but in their ability to disrupt Israel’s national routine to the point of halting financial and economic activity in the country’s heartland: the Gush Dan metropolitan area.
Underlying this strategy is recognition that mosquitoes are far more dangerous to humans than wild beasts. Mosquitoes have killed millions of people throughout the ages, while wild beasts are a relatively rare phenomenon that humans have learned to deal with. Even jungle residents do not regularly encounter lions and leopards in their living quarters, while mosquitoes penetrate the seemingly most protected homes as a matter of course. Recognizing that any attempt to overwhelm the IDF in a frontal assault is doomed to failure, Hamas and Islamic Jihad have sought to exhaust Israel through continuous mosquito-like “stings.”
Finding an adequate response to this strategy is of course an integral part of the IDF’s overall responsibility. But it also depends on the Israeli public’s ability to grasp the nature of the terrorist threat and to shoulder its highly demanding consequences.
For quite some time, the Israeli Left has been telling Israelis of the need to recognize their limits of power and end the “occupation” of the West Bank. In fact, it is not the continued retention of this territory (albeit not its population, which has been ruled since 1996 by the Palestinian Authority) that signifies the limits of Israel’s power, but the IDF’s inability to redress the catastrophic security implications attending such a withdrawal.
Contrary to the belief that the IDF’s prowess will enable it to easily defeat any threat from a prospective Palestinian state, the Gaza experience in general and the latest conflagration in particular illustrate the limits of Israeli power. Even if the IDF is thrown into the fray and achieves an unequivocal victory (something it has been unable to achieve in the three Gaza wars over the past decade), it will still be unable to prevent the prolonged disruption of Israel’s national life through massive rocket and missile attacks on the country’s civilian population. And this is a situation that no Israeli policymaker will readily entertain.
Maj. Gen. (res.) Gershon Hacohen is a senior research fellow at the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies. He served in the IDF for 42 years. He commanded troops in battles with Egypt and Syria. He was formerly a corps commander and commander of the IDF Military Colleges.
A version of this article was originally published by Israel Hayom and The BESA Center.
As Political Lines Blur, Republican Jewish Coalition’s Matt Brooks Warns of a Deeper Shift Facing American Jews
Federal Complaint Alleges Antisemitic Housing Discrimination at Williams College
Democratic Nominee for University of Michigan Regent Refuses to Condemn Hezbollah
Jewish Student Leader Targeted in Two Antisemitic Incidents in Berlin
Duke University Lifts Suspension of Students for Justice in Palestine Despite Acknowledging Group’s Antisemitic Post
Iran Has Executed At Least 21 People, Arrested Over 4,000 Since Start of War With US and Israel, UN Reports
Norwegian Holocaust Center Defends Decision to Host Event Drawing Parallels Between Holocaust, Palestinian ‘Nakba’
‘Intifada Against British Jews’: Two Jewish People Stabbed in London Amid Soaring Antisemitic Attacks
Lebanon Must Reform its Army or Lose American Aid
How to Respond to the Moment: After the Rupture, the Rebuild





Russians Retreat as Al Qaeda-Linked Jihadists, Tuareg Separatists Kill Mali’s Defense Minister, Capture Key Town
Iran Faces Economic Disaster as US Blockade Suffocates Regime’s Oil Lifeline
Palestinian Authority TV Promises Israel ‘Will Pass’ and Cease to Exist
America’s Real ‘Special Relationship’ When the Pageantry Is Stripped Away
How Israel’s Shift from ‘Deliberate Ambiguity’ to ‘Selective Disclosure’ Could Prevent a Catastrophic War



