What Would Happen if America Turned Against Israel — and US Jews?
Error: Contact form not found.
by Jason Shvili

An Israeli flag and an American flag fly at Abu Dhabi International Airport before the arrival of Israeli and US officials, in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, Aug. 31, 2020. Photo: REUTERS/Christoper Pike
The United States is arguably Israel’s greatest friend and ally. But what if it wasn’t anymore? What would American Jews and Israel have to do then?
With the recent election of Zohran Mamdani as the next mayor of New York City, which is home to more Jews than anywhere else in the US, the rise to power of anti-Israel politicians is now more apparent than ever. Indeed, as anti-Israel and antisemitic politics in both the Democratic and Republican parties becomes increasingly popular, it may only be a matter of time before enemies of the Jewish State dominate both houses of Congress, and even the US presidency. If that happens, Israel, its supporters, and all Jewish Americans need to be ready.
How would an anti-Israel US behave? Firstly, it would not support Israel in international forums, like the UN Security Council. As a result, Israel would face severe diplomatic isolation, unlike anything it has ever seen — even worse than the isolation Israel faces now. Indeed, Israel could end up becoming a pariah state like North Korea.
If the US ceases to be its ally, Israel would also likely face severe economic consequences. Currently, the US is Israel’s largest trading partner. Trade between the two countries is valued at $35 to $40 billion a year. Imagine if the US severely cut trade ties with Israel or even stopped trading with Israel entirely. The Israeli economy would be in danger.
Things wouldn’t be better for American Jews or other Americans who support Israel either. In fact, the kind of hostility Jews and supporters of Israel face in the US now might pale in comparison to the hostility they would face if the US was no longer a friend of the Jewish State. Eventually, even state-sponsored antisemitism could occur. In fact, many Jews around the world today will tell you they already feel as if it’s the 1930s all over again.
Both Israel and American Jews should immediately begin preparing for such a nightmarish scenario. There’s no time to waste.
For its part, Israel must be ready for a mass influx of immigration from the US. Absorbing immigrants, however, will probably be the least of Israel’s worries if the US is no longer its ally. The bigger problem will be reducing dependence on the US, especially in regards to military equipment and trade.
In Israel’s formative years, few countries were willing to sell arms to the Jewish State, so Israel had to be as self-sufficient as possible, and manufacture much of its own military equipment. Today, Israel has a thriving arms industry, one of the best in the world. Nevertheless, Israel is still too dependent on US military equipment. This has to change. Israel must undertake efforts to ensure that it can manufacture most if not all its own arms. Everything from ammunition to fighter aircraft. Because if the US ceases to be Israel’s ally, it will severely restrict its sale of arms to the Jewish State, if not stop altogether.
Furthermore, Israel must learn to survive without the US as a major trading partner. It must seek new trade partners and consolidate trade with current partners. Israel should do its utmost to ensure that it is as economically self-sufficient as possible in the event that the US decides to impose crippling sanctions or even a full-scale trade embargo.
Meanwhile, American Jews should prepare for the possibility that they might have to emigrate to Israel if being Jewish in the US becomes impossible and even threatens their lives. A good start would be learning Hebrew.
This is obviously a doomsday scenario, which will hopefully never come to pass. Nonetheless, we should all be prepared for the possibility that, in the future, the US may no longer be Israel’s ally — and might become hostile to all its Jewish citizens. Better to be safe than sorry.
Jason Shvili is a freelance writer and commentator on Jewish affairs, Israel, and the Middle East.
Students Supporting Israel Launch Fall Tour to Promote Black, Ethiopian, Jewish Unity
Trump Says He Has Been ‘Best President’ For Israel, Questions Why Jews Vote Democrat
Majority of American Jews Still Hiding Identity to Avoid Hate Crime, New Survey Reports
Harvard Faculty Pen Letter Detailing Ongoing Antisemitism Crisis On Campus Amid White House Investigation
A New Book Reveals Perhaps the Most Important Lesson of October 7
California Jews Bear Disproportionate Share of Religion-Based Hate Crimes, New State Report Finds
Azerbaijani Jewish Leaders Urge Israel to Halt Armenian Genocide Bill Amid Fears of Strained Baku-Jerusalem Ties
How Latin America’s Political Realignment Is Shaping Israel’s Future
Ahead of the 2028 Presidential Election, Competing Worldviews on Iran Will Be on Full Display
On His Way Out, UNRWA Chief Faces Calls for Criminal Probe Into Hamas Infiltration





How Latin America’s Political Realignment Is Shaping Israel’s Future
A New Book Reveals Perhaps the Most Important Lesson of October 7
Azerbaijani Jewish Leaders Urge Israel to Halt Armenian Genocide Bill Amid Fears of Strained Baku-Jerusalem Ties
Harvard Faculty Pen Letter Detailing Ongoing Antisemitism Crisis On Campus Amid White House Investigation
Students Supporting Israel Launch Fall Tour to Promote Black, Ethiopian, Jewish Unity



